Remote assessment technology has become more relevant as universities, companies, and certification bodies embrace technology to facilitate their respective online exams. However, these institutions that have adopted the use of online assessment systems need to uphold justice in their examinations and refrain from copying each other during the exams. Among the most practiced ways of distance supervision today are live proctoring and AI proctoring. Each is superior in one way or another, and there is no one-size-fits-all approach to safeguarding an examination appropriate model has to be selected-sometimes even both models have to be utilized at the same time.
This article opposes live proctoring and AI Proctoring in terms of advantages, disadvantages, and how to use any of them, depending on the examination requirements of their particular needs. Which factors are taken into account in each case?
How does live proctoring work?
Live proctoring involves the invigilation of candidates in real time by a human invigilator who keeps an eye on the candidates through their webcam, audio, and screen. Interaction with the student, face identity confirmation, and reporting of questionable behavior are all possible by the proctor.
Salient Features of Live Proctoring
-
Candidates are overseen by human proctors in real time
-
Human observation is used to detect any suspicious activities
-
The proctor can communicate with the test-taker
-
Highly recommended for professional exams and high-stakes tests
-
It is of great emotional benefit to some, reducing test anxiety
Live proctoring is used when the use of a physical examination hall is to be replicated and is preferred in cases where a human decision is required in the assessment.
What Does AI Proctoring Mean?
Monitoring an online exam automatically is the purpose of AI Proctoring. There is no need for a human to monitor any activities in this case – neural networks track any suspicious actions, noises, focus of gaze, devices, people, and so on. In addition, the system structures reports after all the relevant examination activities have been conducted.
Salient Features of Proctor AI
-
Machine-learning system for automatic supervision
-
Capabilities like face detection and activity observation
-
Verification of the person in question at different intervals
-
Capable of supporting a large number of populations
-
Coming up with comprehensive statistics and corrective plans
The fact that even thousands of examinations can be conducted at the same time without any help of human therein, the idea of AI Proctoring in mass exams has become very common.
The Difference between Live and AI Proctoring
-
Means of Control
While live proctoring is centered around the visual impressions of humans looking at students, AI relies on computers performing detection and analytics automatically.
-
Credibility and Skills
However, in the case of AI proctoring, documents with the correct proofreading will be printed and ready for dispatch to them.
-
Pure Operational Management
The candidate’s slideshow is run online, and in return, at the time of the performance, the candidate is evenly spaced as all is enabled via the software’s advanced features.
Humans can recognize people’s emotions and feelings, context and even how they behave. On the other hand, AI is methodical, free of any prejudices and not tired, although it will sometimes raise an alarm for a perfectly safe conduct.
-
Scalability
With live proctoring a single invigilator is only able to screen a set amount of learners rendering makes it very difficult. On the other hand, the AI proctoring can cater for large numbers of examinees all at the same time.
-
Cost
This is more costly since an additional form of traditional proctoring incorporates people which means purchase or location will take place too. AI supervision costs fall significantly when many tests are conducted.
-
Candidate Experience
When administered live, there is interaction; when administered under the computerized mode popularly known as AI proctoring the session is passive.
Best Use Cases
The live attack is more applicable in cases of high-stake examinations; AI proctoring is more relevant in situations including educational, commercial and seminar assessments.
Advantages of AI Proctoring
1. Provides human control in the process.
Human invigilators come with the requisite skill set and knowledge to understand and manage each situation themselves. They judiciously recognize and analyse the difference between innocent errors and smart cheating.
2. Immediate action
In a real and in situ scenario, a proctor can say something or do something (eg, stop the exam). Anything!
3. Credibility
Most of the organizations conducting examinations believe in their supervision level offered by human proctors.
4. Technological support is always at hand
It is quite beneficial for the exam experience since test takers can ask for any assistance during their examinations.
Benefits of AI proctoring
1. Can cater to a large number of people at the same time
AI proctoring allows for to supervision of thousands of students simultaneously, which is why it is ideal for distance education schools, colleges, and big corporations.
2. No Additional Costs
A vague observation is that after the system is set up, the need for manual labor does not rise.
3. Fair Monitoring
Artificial intelligence cannot get fatigued or bored. It can enforce disciplinary measures around the exams in a consistent and continuous manner.
4. Comprehensive Analytics Data
Examiners receive information such as context of unusual activities, recordings, and other supporting evidence, with the time periods for such activities helping in the decision process.
5. Improved Accessibility
The use of AI makes it possible for the candidates to attempt their examinations from any location- of course, with constant supervision.
When is it Appropriate to Use AI Proctoring?
Live proctoring can be used in certain situations which can include:
-
Examinations with high stakes or fit in for professional certificates
-
More likelihood of getting fake tests
-
Where human skills are needed for behavior assessments
-
There is a need for communication along the line
-
Direct reassurances to the candidates ensure equality during the testing sessions.
Such exams include medical licensing, international licensing as well as administrative recruitment which cannot be undertaken without live proctoring because of the criticality of the examinations and their process.
When is it Appropriate to Use AI Proctoring?
AI proctoring is most appropriate for:
-
Tertiary institutions taking term or final examinations
-
Companies assessing their staff
-
Mass education or selective systems
-
Standardizing agencies with a wide outreach
-
Exams with low to medium levels of security
For the institutions that want automation and comfort along with managing the scale, the shift towards AI in proctoring proves to be very useful.
The Perfect Blueprint: Merging the Two with Hybrid Proctoring
A hybrid model integrates the best of live proctoring and AI proctoring into a comprehensive system of regulation.
The Mechanics
-
All candidates will be monitored all the time by artificial intelligence, which will also note any deviations.
-
Human proctors will only take these cases or high-risk candidates under their supervision.
-
There is minimal cost to the institution for proctoring without compromising the security of the exam.
Advantages of Hybrid Proctoring
-
Reduced false positives
-
Increased efficiency through human and AI cooperation
-
Fewer resources, thus reducing costs
-
Improved the candidate’s perception
-
Restrictions on the monitoring upon the exam offered
This brings into play more development of the ideas, such that while each process is automated, expertise is included on the ground.
AI Proctoring: What Will Change in the Security of Examinations Over the Internet
With the advancement within the field of artificial intelligence, behavior tracking, and facial analytics at speed, it is only a matter of time before AI Proctoring becomes the holy grail of online evaluation. Suspicious behavior alerts, identity management, and examination over vigilance allow AI proctoring to provide solutions for years beyond.
Over time, as institutions and international organizations embrace more digital ways of evaluation, AI Proctoring will remain vital in promoting fairness, transparency, and integrity.
When seeking a company to provide proctoring services, consider Think Exam
Think Exam has:
-
Live Proctoring
-
Advanced AI Proctoring
-
Hybrid Proctoring
-
Instant biometric checks
-
Secure browser without exit
-
Analysis of the results
With a user-friendly interface as well as robust architecture, Think Exam is among the best platforms for conducting exams online in a safe manner.
FAQs
1. Are there any important questions concerning the differences between live proctoring and AI proctoring?
Through AI proctoring, real-time monitoring of exams by a person is done, while on the other hand, AI proctoring employs algorithms to look out for and trigger alerts on a number of suspected breaches during the exam.
2. Does live proctoring better protect an exam than AI proctoring?
They both do since AI proctoring is more scalable and uniform, while relying on human proctors develops better judgments in more obscure cases.
3. May live invigilators ever be totally substituted by automatic AI proctoring?
No in practice. AI systems are beneficial when monitoring significant numbers; however, human proctors are essential when the test is high-stakes and decisions are more complex.
4. What’s a hybrid proctoring system?
A combination of AI surveillance and human intervention, a hybrid proctoring system provides the most accurate and efficient results.
5. What form of examination security does your institution require?
On what kind of exam? How big is the scale? How much risk is there? Extensive exams call for the use of AI proctoring systems, and important examinations may require live or combined proctoring.
