Recruiting the right talent is an important process for any organization; if pre-employment assessments have become a standard part of the recruitment process, an assessment process is likely to be incomplete without behavioural testing and employment personality assessment. But which one is better suited to evaluate candidate skills? The answer lies primarily in what an employer seeks—certain job-specific behaviours or long-term personality traits.
Let us examine the differences between these two assessments and figure out which one works best for various hiring needs.
Understanding Behavioural Tests
Behavioural tests are meant to predict how a candidate would act in certain job-related situations. These assessments are concerned with past experiences, problem-solving skills, and responses to workplace challenges.
How Behavioural Tests Work:
Questions put to candidates will be situational or hypothetical workplace scenarios; candidates thus must choose answers they themselves would give based on their own natural behaviour or their own past experiences. The outcomes of these behavioural tests help establish how candidates cope with pressure, teamwork, leadership, and decision-making skills.
Benefits of Behavioural Tests
- Job-specific insights: These tests assess behaviours that directly bear on performance in a given role.
- Real-world applicability: Candidates are evaluated based on how they would behave in situations relevant to the workplace.
- Predicts immediate job performance: Beneficial for jobs that require immediate decisions and adaptability.
The Downside to Behavioural Tests:
- Limited personality insights: These do not assess core, stable personality traits.
- Situational dependency: Candidates may choose answers they feel the employer wants to hear.
Best For:
- Jobs where definite and specific skills are required, e.g., customer service, sales, management.
- When employers want to see how candidates behave in real-world job situations.
Understanding Employment Personality Assessments
Employment Personality Assessments measure selected candidate traits of personality, aspirations, and preferences for the style of working. These tests aren’t about skill but rather how a person instinctively thinks, feels, and interacts with others.
How Personality Assessments Work
Candidates are asked about their preferences, feelings, and behavior-like tendencies.
These answers are analyzed, conglomerating them into basic traits of extraversion, agreeableness, emotional stability, and conscientiousness.
Using the results of the assessment, the employer surveys the candidate’s fit to the job and organization, or leadership potential, or cultural fit.
Pros of Personality Assessments:
- Long-term job fit – This helps predict whether a candidate will flourish in the company work culture.
- Self-awareness and development: Candidates will learn about strengths and weaknesses.
- Diverse team building-The employers can build balanced teams with countering personality types.
Cons of Personality Assessments:
- Does not assess skills-These tests are focused on traits, not skills that contribute to doing the job.
- Time-consuming-Some assessments take long and candidates may find it repetitive.
Best For:
- Positions demanding strategic thinking, leadership, or creativity.
- Employers interested in cultural fit and long-term potential rather than immediate job skills.
How do you assess which test is most appropriate for your organization?
Use Behavioral Tests If:
- There are high demands for problem-solving, quick thinking, and adaptability.
- You wish to assess how the candidate responds to real-life job challenges.
- The focus is on short-term job performance rather than long-term characteristics.
Use Personality Assessments If:
- You want to assess long-term potential, leadership capabilities, and compatibility with the team.
- The job requires interpersonal skills, emotional intelligence, or strategic thinking to a high degree.
- You are concerned about cultural fit rather than immediate job performance.
From the list above, which is preferred? Both!
Behavioral tests assess candidates’ performance in specific job-related situations. Personality tests verify whether candidates are aligned with the values and long-term goals of the firm. Using the two together makes for a more holistic recruitment process that balances skills with cultural consideration.
Conclusion
The selection of a behavioral test versus a personality test is supplementary; the determination of which to use will stem from the hiring objectives of the organization, which will lead to the selection of the best candidates.
When it comes to job-related performance indicators, behavioral tests get the job done. When gauging suitability regarding a candidate’s long-term potential and compatibility with a team, personality tests are appropriate.
Combining the tests promotes a more wholesome hiring strategy, ensuring responsive organizations with synergistic teams that thrive over time.
Looking for the best pre-employment testing solutions?
Think Exam offers unique assessment tools that help you make the right hiring decision.
Check out our platform and request your free demo today!
Frequently Asked Questions
- What distinguishes behavioral tests from personality assessments?
While behavioral tests assess how the candidate would react to job-related situations, personality assessments focus on long-term characteristics, working style, and cultural fit.
- Which test is considered more useful, behavioral test or personality assessments?
Neither is generally better; it all depends on the need for hiring. Behavioral tests are aimed at understanding performance in a specific job whereas personality assessments look for long-term potential and compatibility in existing teams.
- Can I use both behavioral tests and personality assessments together?
Yes. A combination of both tests provides a fuller view of candidates, balancing specific job skills with longer-term cultural fit.
- Which tests are better for customer service positions?
The behavioral tests become more relevant to assess problem-solving, adaptability, and communication in job-relevant situations.
- How long does it take to conduct personality assessments?
These vary in length but are generally longer than behavioral tests due to the deeper level of personality traits they assess.
- Do behavioral tests ensure that people will work?
Behavioral tests offer potentially valid insights into how a would-be employee might act in an actual work situation. Still, success cannot be guaranteed because other factors, such as training and the work environment, would play a role.
- Are personality assessments relevant to leadership roles?
Yes; personality assessments can measure potential for leadership, strategic thinking, and emotional intelligence, all key for such positions.
- Can I actually implement behavioral and personality tests during recruitment?
Many platforms such as Think Exam offer customizable pre-employment testing solutions that can be tailored toward any hiring standard.
